February 6, 2019 Andrea Isley
"Very clean, comfortable bed, great location!"
October 8, 2018 Dana H.
"20 years plus we have stayed at By the Bay Motel and each year we can't wait to come back! This summer was extra special to share with our friends to celebrate a friend's son wedding in Door County! 2 large outdoor patio seating for all of us to share laughs together, beautiful view of the Bay right across the street and of course , Mary and John,owners and their team were so helpful and the rooms were spotless! Can't say enough about the friendliness and beautiful flowers that grace the property. I have told my friends from home about this gem in Fish Creek and they "got it" this summer!!!"
October 8, 2018 Happy Campers
Great Weekend!"We just spent the past weekend at By the Bay Motel in Fish Creek and it was a wonderful location! We were a group of 19 friends in town for a wedding and this was the perfect accommodation for us. After the Friday night wedding festivities were over, we had the rest of the weekend to bike and hike in Peninsula State Park, hangout at the beach that is right across the street, walk to all of the shops and restaurants in Fish Creek and spend time together at the motel. By the Bay has great outdoor space for groups to gather and we did just that! The rooms had everything we needed and were very clean. The king bed was comfortable and our room had a great view of the bay. I think everyone in our group would be happy to stay there again."
August 6, 2018 Keith & Margaret Kiehnau
"Great to see you and John. We really enjoyed staying at your hotel and we look forward to next time. There will be a next time!"
August 6, 2018 Barb P.
"We stayed here in May for our anniversary. Our room was clean and had a view of the water. It is within walking distance of shopping and food. The only thing that would have like was to have a coffee making in the room. If you are just looking for a place to sleep at night this is the place for you. It is fin the middle of all the surrounding towns that are easy driving distances."