October 9, 2017 Bill Tuttle
"A quaint little motel in the heart of Fish Creek within walking distance of restaurants, shops, beach & parks. Just down the street from Fish Creek's Sunset Park. It's a "must see" in the evening! Clean rooms with comfortable beds, TV & refrigerator in every room. Fresh coffee in the office every morning! The owners, John & Mary are very friendly and accommodating. It's a great place to stay while vacationing in Door County! I look forward to my next visit!"
October 9, 2017 John Forster
"Great little motel in the heart of Fish Creek. Within walking distance of restaurants and shopping and across from a park with a beach. Rooms are impeccably clean and perfectly maintained. And the customer service is over the top. A perfect place to call home for a few days!"
June 21, 2017 Bonnie Botoske
"My recent stay at By the Bay Motel was wonderful. The room was clean. Mary and her husband were welcoming. Walking distance to a good restaurant for breakfast. A view of the bay. I would stay here again. "