February 12, 2018 Susan Schankin
"Location is great for all of the activities in North Door County. However, the beds need to be updated. The mattress was larger than the box spring and the sheets don't stay on the bed. AC runs continuously unless you turn it off. Time for some improvements."
December 6, 2017 Tamra Mcmahon
"Stayed two nights and everything was great. Nice little quaint motel. Great location. No hassle. I would definitely stay again . Thanks by the bay"
December 6, 2017 Jennifer Klumpyan-Dougherty
"We spend our anniversary in Door County every year and the last 4 years it has been at By The Bay in Fish Creek. A quaint place in the heart of Fish Creek where you can walk to all the shops and restaurants. The owners are very accommodating. We look forward to our yearly stay."
December 6, 2017 Gary Van Straten
"We've been staying at By the Bay in Fish Creek every time we're in Door County. So close to everything we love, biking, kayaking and shopping! John and Mary are super friendly and treat you like family. Rooms are so clean, comfy beds and great to have a frig. In every room."
December 6, 2017 Cindy Middleton Jayes
"We come here every year, we love it! The access is great, as it's right across the street from Fish creek park! The owners, Mary and John, are super sweet people. It's a quaint place, very sweet."